What Clients Actually Want: Shocking Insights From the Agency-Client Benchmark Report 2025 with Remeny Armitage
What are the surprising findings about client awareness of agency services, and how can agencies bridge this gap?
In this episode, I sit down with Remeny Armitage once again, Founder of Brilliant and Human, to discuss the intricacies of client-agency relationships. Remeny’s extensive research reveals a surprising gap: 40% of agencies acknowledge that their clients might not fully understand the breadth of services they offer. We get into the significance of genuine engagement and human connection in business, exploring how these elements can transform success and client retention. Remeny also provides insight on the role of AI and powerful strategies to enhance agency-client dynamics.
We later uncover strategies that shift agency-client interactions from transactional to relationship-driven. This includes drawing fascinating parallels with the consulting industry, highlighting how building commercial confidence within agency teams can position them as trusted advisors. This not only enhances client loyalty, but also opens doors for growth. From refining onboarding and communication processes to moving from hourly billing to value-based engagements, this episode reveals all!
Topics covered during this episode include:
Why authentic engagement and humanity are pivotal in client retention and success.
How looking at similarities in the consulting industry can help agencies become trusted advisors.
Why refining onboarding and communication processes enhance the client experience.
How transitioning from hourly billing to value-oriented engagements benefits both agencies and clients.
Why agencies should market their services effectively to existing clients.
How proactive strategic thinking and challenging client assumptions drive loyalty.
Why building commercial confidence within agency teams leads to better client interactions.
Why agencies need to demonstrate human value amidst AI advancements in the industry.
How improving agency-client dynamics can unlock new revenue streams and opportunities.
Listen now to uncover the surprising dynamics of client-agency partnerships and learn how to become a trusted advisor!
00:00 - Remeny (Guest) The agency clients nine times out of 10, again are not aware of all the things that agencies do. So it might be strategy, it might be design, whatever it might be, they often aren't aware of it and when I was interviewing the agencies, there's something like 40% of agencies recognize that their clients probably don't know what they do other than the core service they do.
00:24 - Mike (Host) My name's Mike Lander and you're listening to Higgle, the B2B sales club podcast, where we bring you actionable insights about sales, RFPs, negotiations and difficult procurement discussions from sales leaders, brand leaders and procurement leaders. Please subscribe to get updates when new episodes are released. Remini, thanks ever so much for joining me on the second version of the Higgle B2B Salesforce podcast. Great to have you back.
00:53 - Remeny (Guest) Oh, it's great to be here. Thanks for having me.
00:55 - Mike (Host) And for the audience. The reason that Remini's kindly agreed to come back on the show is that she's just done a very big piece of research into what clients want, how clients work with agencies, what the feedback is. So we're going to get a perspective from Remini about basically the client side perspective, about agency working and agency relationships and why it works and why it doesn't. Remini just to remind people who are listening who are you, what do you do?
01:19 - Remeny (Guest) I am Remini Armitage. I'm the founder of Brilliant and Human and I help agencies understand what their clients really think, to help them uncover new services, opportunities, issues, difficulties in the agency, but with the idea that by being more human and engaging with your clients and your teams, you can be more successful and better and brilliant. But it's all about humanity in business.
01:43 - Mike (Host) And also retain your clients.
01:44 - Remeny (Guest) Well, of course, that's the key part Keep them happy and retained.
01:48 - Mike (Host) Keep them happy and retained. Yes, deliver excellent results, retain your clients and you will grow Exactly as opposed to you want to grow and you want to retain somehow. And then, thirdly, you think about excellent results, which is clearly a disaster.
02:02 - Remeny (Guest) Yes, and I suppose I should have probably added to that. The way I do it is I interview people's clients and find out what they're really thinking and get that real truth and the insight from what they actually think. Looking at the bigger picture, looking at what the themes are of what your clients actually think and want, can then help you to actually address any opportunities or issues that you might be having, to help you improve.
02:23 - Mike (Host) So first of all, do you want to just point out where people can find the report?
02:26 - Remeny (Guest) Thank you very much. You can find it on my website, which is brilliantandhumancom, on the homepage. It's very easy to find.
02:33 - Mike (Host) Perfect, very good indeed. So let's get into just a bit about the kind of methodology. Even before that, what were you trying to do? Why did you think about doing this?
02:41 - Remeny (Guest) Because, as I know, they are a massive undertaking for people like us. So why did you do it? Well, my background I've worked in-house in agencies for 20 plus years, so I kind of understood the agency side, and then, with all my client interviews, I was getting a real sense of the need to answer. The question that agencies always ask me is what do my clients think? Over the years, people would be asking what are the common themes, what do clients really think? And as it went along, there are certain themes that always come up, which I'm sure we'll be covering today, and I just thought it'd be really interesting to analyze what clients think compared to what agencies think clients think, if that's not too much of a tongue twister. And it came up with some really interesting results that surprised me. My thinking was I wanted to, as every writer does. You think you're going to have one result, and this is the lesson I'm going to be sharing and in actual fact it wasn't what I thought it was going to be, and so it was a bit of a surprise.
03:39 - Mike (Host) So we will come to that. We'll come to that, yes, probably midway through, and then summarize them at the end. But okay, so what was the methodology? So what did you do?
03:48 - Remeny (Guest) Initially I interviewed a range of agency leaders, agency owners for different sizes, different types from the creative digital content marketing, all sorts of different agency types. I did quite in-depth interviews and some online but mostly interviews with 60 agencies and then I compared that with the insight that I've gleaned from 140, 150 client interviews. So obviously it was all completely anonymous, but it was interesting to see the results that came and the comparisons to give a sense of it. Interesting to see the results that came and the comparisons to give a sense of it. So it wasn't hundreds of thousands that some people do, but it was more intensely kind of detailed of what people thought. So it was very much there's quantitative analysis, but the majority is qualitative analysis throughout and it's kind of looking at everything from what the client journey is, from onboarding the relationships throughout the strategy and in comparisons of what the agency owners, as I said, think compared to what the clients think.
04:50 The other thing I should say is I also had a number of agency experts, consultants contribute to the report with essays, so their thinking is put throughout, occasionally challenging me. So there's a bit of discussions that go on, especially around AI, through the report, and so then their essays articles are at the back of the report as well, so it's not just me talking, it's other agency experts as well, and then it's filled with, off the back of all of that, lots of kind of recommendations for how to improve things, as well as kind of the insight from both clients, agencies and experts and me.
05:29 - Mike (Host) Perfect, let's talk about your top three or five insights that came out, and then let's talk about what are the top three or five responses that agencies should be looking at as a real headline.
05:40 - Remeny (Guest) Yeah, that's a big question. Well, I think I'm not sure I'm going to exactly answer your question as you've asked it.
05:46 - Mike (Host) As you want to Remini. It's entirely up to you.
05:48 - Remeny (Guest) I mean the three things that clients complain about, from my experience, the most. Actually, I'm not going to start with that the things that agencies thought the clients complained about the most. It was looking at the processes and communication, and the third one they thought was pricing. But in actual fact, this was one of the surprises that came out of their report was that actually it's not pricing. It never is. Clients don't complain about pricing. No, it's not about pricing.
06:16 - Mike (Host) It's about the value you deliver.
06:17 - Remeny (Guest) It's a myth and how you deliver it Exactly. If a client likes you, trusts you, knows that you're doing a good job. It's not about the money. It's about being transparent.
06:26 - Mike (Host) Remini, I'm glad you've said this because I've been saying it for years to agencies and they don't believe me. They always think it's about the price and I always say it's about the value. And as you get into bigger companies it's even more about the value. Yes, and if you can't demonstrate the value that you deliver to that client versus the price that you charge, and demonstrate that there is a good return on that investment that they are making, then more for you as an agency.
06:54 - Remeny (Guest) Exactly, and I think the big thing around that is good communication, and I've got a whole chapter dedicated to communication and the importance of it. And it's being open, it's being honest, it's about being transparent and I think things like retainers that often come up and those are one of the things that cause the biggest irritation with clients. That's when the money does come up is when they don't know what's being done for the money. What are they getting for it? Yeah, what are they getting, and so that can often cause problems, but it's very much about the value, but flipping that. The three things that clients do complain about is lack of proactivity, lack of processes and lack of communication or inadequate communication, and the thing that kind of encompasses all of that is setting expectations and good onboarding and the importance of good onboarding, good onboarding and the importance of good onboarding and that when I was doing the agency interviews, 53% of agencies recognized that onboarding was an issue. I think that's something that needs to be addressed in the agency world.
07:55 - Mike (Host) Absolutely. We were talking before about in the consulting world. When you start a new program of work with a client especially a net new client, but even an existing client you'd have an onboarding program. As the program director, part of my job was to make sure that I'd onboarded our consultants so they knew who the client was and what they were looking for. I'd onboard the client's consultants. I'd talk to the executive on the client side. I'd talk to our partners on our side. I'd run through a methodology we used to do what we used to call a fast start. So we'd run the entire program that we're going to run with the client. We'd run it in kind of a day, so we'd simulate it, and then we'd get people in and then we'd get the client in and we'd talk about the outcomes and the scope of work and what's in the contract versus what's been said and what their expectations are versus what's been written down. You know better than me. Do agencies do all that? Do they have a structured onboarding methodology?
08:50 - Remeny (Guest) That's debatable? Yeah, most don't. From my experience, most don't. I mean many of the agencies I've spoken to. Some of them said oh yeah, we've got onboarding. Some of my clients have said it, but it's something that they do at the very beginning. It's part of the contract, it's just paper, it's not. And then another thing I hear a lot of is it costs too much to do proper onboarding and it's like no, no, no, you are going to be losing a lot of money. I have a great example of an agency I was interviewing for, where I was interviewing a marketing director client and they were saying I'm new to the business. I've been using them for now for six months. I took over and I've been asking them to source some imagery for us. I'm not sure if it's in scope, I don't know. They've never said not to worry about it, so I've just continued to do it. And then, of course, when I spoke to the client, they said yeah, it's not in scope and we don't know how to deal with it.
09:42 - Mike (Host) And I was like you need to onboard your clients, not just at the beginning, but in the middle of the project, especially if you've got new team members, both your clients and your team members. So if you've got new people, they need to be onboarded.
09:57 - Remeny (Guest) When stakeholders change, you re-onboard them. Yeah, I've got a chapter in my report which is how to help your clients be better clients, because one of the things I asked to the agencies was we all know I mean, I worked in-house in agencies for 20 odd years we all know that clients can be a problem and can be really annoying and actually what is it that is the most annoying things that clients do. But actually most of those things that the agencies identified that you know I discussed were things that if you onboarded properly at the beginning and you kept on top of it, you set those expectations and set those rules down, you could help your clients be better clients, help them be happier and don't let them take the mickey, avoiding scope creep and avoiding loss of so much money.
10:40 - Mike (Host) Because, on the whole, my experience with clients is certainly in bigger clients is they're complex stakeholder environments. People move jobs, people come and go, people leave, people arrive. Priorities change on a quarterly basis based upon what's happened to the company and what the board has said. Well, all of that. It's not the client's job to tell the agency all about this. It's the agency's job, for the fee they're getting paid, to understand the context of the client and all the moving parts. That's the agency's job.
11:12 - Remeny (Guest) And to bring insights and bring something new to the table Exactly, and I think that leads on nicely to another thing that comes up a lot in the interviews I do. Where the agency clients often say to me is that the agencies aren't proactive enough in their thinking and their strategic thinking. They haven't taken the time to understand us as a business and what our goals are, and I think that they need to take the time to focus on what the clients actually need and want and be challenging. So again, a lot of clients say to me I wish the agency would be more challenging. They know what they're doing. They need to come to us and push back. Sometimes. Don't just be yes people, which I think again, when you've got the younger generation, then that can be harder, but it's about training the younger generation to be able to speak up.
11:58 - Mike (Host) Challenge appropriately. Yeah, let's just dig into that again. So the feedback you've had, the irrefutable feedback, is clients absolutely want more proactive strategic thinking and more challenge. Yeah, so where you go? Okay, so why? If you think about any big company and you think about what's going on inside that company and all the market pressures, on a quarterly basis, things will have changed. Performance will have changed If their listed share price will have moved. Well, they need support. They need challenging thinking to challenge their assumptions, to help them grow. They need you to be proactive about, well, what might happen in the next two quarters. Where might the market go? What scenarios could play out? What have we seen as an agency across all our clients in the sectors that we specialize in which is one of yours, hopefully as a client about what the direction of travel is? That's our job as agencies, surely?
12:52 - Remeny (Guest) It is absolutely. However, I think one of the other problems I hear and I think is one of the issues around this is because agencies aren't charging for it enough. So, again, when I interview clients, I'll often say funny enough, you said the quarterly thing is the agency is thinking about running quarterly strategic sessions with their clients. Would you be interested in having these sessions with them? Yeah, but charge for it because it takes time to repair, it takes time to do it, it takes time to respond and nine times out of 10, the clients say yes and then that's just automatically opened up an opportunity to uncover a new revenue feeder. I've got a client that I did that with. Within a year they were making 40% profit because not only were they charging for those sessions, they were then actually uncovering so much more new work that they were able to uncover new opportunities.
13:42 Which again brings me to another area that is again highlighted in the report is the fact that the agency clients nine times out of 10, again are not aware of all the things that agencies do. So it might be strategy, it might be design, whatever it might be. They often aren't aware of it and when I was interviewing the agencies, there's something like 40% of agencies recognize that their clients probably don't know what they do other than the core service they do. It was only 12% said yeah, I'm confident our clients know. I don't have a number for what the clients said because it's one of those things that it's harder to put that back, but from my experience when interviewing them, it's amazing how often the clients don't know what they do and then they go oh yes, we'd like that.
14:28 - Mike (Host) Again, I draw parallels with the consulting world for good reason, which is, if you look at the margins in the consulting world, the consulting world, the high-end consulting world, makes very good margins for good reasons, for all sorts of reasons you won't get into now, but they make good margins, not super normal profits, but they make good margins, a good business margin. If you look at agencies, they're often really struggling with margins, like really, really struggling with margins. So you say, well, why is that? Part of it is the big consultancy firms have a client partner. Client partner's job is to manage the client relationship.
15:01 Yes, client partner might have six partners working for them on very big clients who deliver pieces of work as the client lead, as the kind of partner lead. But the client partner oversees everything. They might oversee operational consultancy, strategy, consultancy, performance improvement, consultancy, all sorts of white lines. Because as the client partner and the client partner's job is to engage with the client and to find opportunities and to talk about the broader services that the consulting firm offers and go to conferences with them and do all sorts is to act as the strategic input to the client at the very highest level. Yes, agencies I don't think do that effectively anywhere near, even if they've got account directors. It's very rare to find someone that can engage at that kind of level and that causes big problems. Yeah, because you're just not relevant.
15:52 - Remeny (Guest) I think it's about building those commercial confidence to have the conversations that you want and need to have, and I think I do a workshop that's kind of embracing commerciality and it's about getting the teams within the agencies to feel confident about having those human conversations with their clients that give them the ability to share things that they might be doing with other clients, to understand their businesses more and feel like you can have those engaged human relationships which enable you to open up opportunities.
16:21 But I think, again, it's one of those things that agencies often don't prioritize because it costs money and it costs time. They think that the teams are so busy doing the doing that they find it very difficult to go beyond that. And it's kind of why I do what I do, because actually often I'll find that you know you're not prioritizing those older clients or nurturing those older clients. They're the ones you've already built the relationships. Look at opportunities for how you can open up the conversations to enable you to develop new work. But it's not about necessarily finding the work today. It's about having the relationship that's strong enough for when they have the time the clients are ready. You go for it and they know they'll call you because you've got a good enough relationship, or when they move to another business.
17:04 - Mike (Host) I think it's also about being a business advisor, especially now, especially given that the generative AI engines are very good at giving clients pretty good answers to quite complex questions. You need to be the trusted advisor, yes, but those are easy words to say. You need to understand how the client's business works financially, how it works operationally, how it works in market, what its strategy is. You need to have a pretty broad business understanding. If you're going to walk into the CMO and have this kind of conversation but you don't understand what's marketing's contribution to sales uplift and what margin are we generating by product range and where should we be investing across different channels to get the maximum return to generate more sales at an appropriate profit margin, if you can't have that conversation because they've not been trained in agency world to do that, you're always going to be delivering a piece of work and unable to get a seat at the table.
18:01 - Remeny (Guest) Yeah, you'll just be the doer, the deliverer. It's not relationship-led, it's got to be delivering a piece of work and unable to get a seat at the table. Yeah, you'll just be the doer, the deliverer. It's not relationship-led, it's got to be relationship-led. I've actually just done a post about kind of the importance of that teamwork and your team is your clients and your team and you've got to work together for success and actually without that, if you're just going to be a commodity, then, as you say, you're going to be short-lived.
18:27 - Mike (Host) It'll be short-lived, it'll be less than a year. So just talk to us now about what are your kind of top two or three findings that agencies need to really think about as themes coming from your client kind of research. What are the two or three big themes that agencies need to be thinking about on a regular basis when they're looking across all their clients and about how they retain and how they grow and how they make appropriate levels of profit?
18:49 - Remeny (Guest) I think there's two areas that encompass a huge amount and hopefully answer all of that. The first one is look at how you can help your client be a better client and what does that entail. So make sure, right from day one, you have good onboarding. So, again, I work for a lot of agencies who do customer experience and journey plans for all their clients, but they're not very good at doing it for themselves. And actually, if you sat down and looked at what your client journey is and looked at how you could improve everything from the onboarding to the communication to the processes, what are those touch points? What are those commercial touch points? How am I going to get to know my clients better? How am I going to nurture those relationships to make you that trusted advisor? And make sure you're getting the feedback throughout the relationship as well and, where needed, get someone outside or someone in-house that isn't involved daily. Get that feedback so that your clients feel heard and listened to. But make sure that you're asking the right questions and whether or not it's about getting to know whether they've got family or they're going on holiday or what would make them look better in the future, what's their personal goal. So it's getting to know the client right from day one.
19:55 The second part, which again hopefully covers all of this, is the idea that, like I said, clients often don't know what the agencies do. So actually think about marketing to your existing clients. How do you differentiate yourself? How are you indispensable to your clients? There's so much competition out there it is difficult to differentiate yourself, but actually it's very often it's the people that differentiate you.
20:20 But make sure that you have those relationships, that the clients know that. But make sure you are as clear about your own marketing to your clients. So make sure your clients know what you do. Make sure you can have those open relationships. Be clear in what you do. Make sure you're talking about what you're doing for your other clients. I mean, a lot of clients say to me, you know, I wish they did events where I got to meet the other clients because I'd like to learn from them. It's remember to being human and building those human relationships and to build that loyalty. So it's not just about the process, it's not just about the money, it's about building human relationships and that's on both sides. But I think, as I say, it's setting yourself up well and making sure you're building those relationships ongoing.
21:03 - Mike (Host) And demonstrating value. I mean, I think, going back to what you said at the beginning, you have to know what value you create for that client. There are many ways to measure value, some of which are pure financial and some aren't. Yeah, but you've got to work out what your map from. You have this problem that we're solving for you. We charge you a fee per month or on a project basis, or whatever it might be to do that, and this is the value it creates. When I spoke to Caroline Johnson from the Business Model Company the other day on the podcast about the urgent need for agencies to shift away from time and materials-based and services-based mindset into products and outputs, and outcomes.
21:42 - Remeny (Guest) I mean, we haven't mentioned AI, but I think AI that's causing obviously a lot of fear and worry and it's how do you use that? But I do think that, with the whole value piece, it's even more important that you show your value as a human in business and that your experience and what you bring can't be repeated by AI. Yes, of course it can help. Support A lot of the discussions I'm having with people is the idea that, of course, the clients are saying well, you're charging me five hours when you're using AI I'm sure of it and so surely you should be charging me one hour Can't be about the hour. It's got to be about the value you bring.
22:18 - Mike (Host) So towards the end of the podcast which we are heading towards the end of the podcast which we are heading towards the end of the client's partly to blame for this. So the client's like I want to compensate you on an hourly rate model, yes, and then I want you to use AI and I want you to therefore reduce the number of hours that you deliver to me, yes. Well, that's not a value conversation, no, that's just a rate card hour conversation. So that's a ridiculous way to manage a commercial relationship between a brand and a supplier. You're never going to get success for either party if you adopt that model. I've always thought it's crackers.
22:51 - Remeny (Guest) It is. That's about when you become the commodity. We're not buying nails. No, you need to be relationship-led, and if you've got clients who are talking that way, then you probably need to fire them.
23:01 - Mike (Host) Maybe they're the wrong clients.
23:03 - Remeny (Guest) I mean I have a number of times told my clients they should fire various clients because actually the clients are causing more headaches, they're being difficult and ridiculous, but obviously I don't do that too often but it has happened.
23:15 - Mike (Host) I can hear agencies now probably shouting at their car radios or phones saying yes, but we get beaten up by procurement all the time and all they want is day rates. I'm like well, if you let them, yes, if you can't explain the value you create and a different commercial model, then ultimately, if they've been told to procure you, they will buy you on whatever basis they can. If you yield to their. Well, I want you on an hourly basis and I want you to give me timesheets.
23:43 - Remeny (Guest) well, in some ways, more for the agency, yeah exactly, and you've got to have those open relationships, those open conversations.
23:49 - Mike (Host) You have Just say we don't charge an hourly rate basis. By all means, you can have our rate card. There's a rate card by type of person that we have. However, we never, ever, charge on an hourly rate or daily rate basis. No, it just doesn't work, but you're very welcome to have the rate card.
24:05 - Remeny (Guest) Yeah, it's having those open, honest conversations. I mean, again, there's so many different areas we could jump into, but I'm conscious of time.
24:12 - Mike (Host) Rowan, it's been fantastic. Thank you for coming on and sharing the insights from the research report.
24:17 - Remeny (Guest) Thank you, just remind everyone again where can they download the report? I've got a copy of it here. It's the Agency Client Benchmark Report and you can get it from my website at brilliantandhumancom and I'd love to be able to send it to you. It's free and it's quite a big document full of different chapters. As I said, that we've covered today. So thank you so much.
24:38 - Mike (Host) I know that you're very active on LinkedIn. I'm sure you'd welcome engagement on LinkedIn around exactly this topic.
24:43 - Remeny (Guest) Absolutely yes. I'm easy to find. I'm the only Remini Armitage around.
24:47 - Mike (Host) You are Exactly Thanks. Ever so much for joining me on Higgle, the B2B podcast.
24:51 - Remeny (Guest) Thank you so much. I really appreciate it. Thank you.
24:55 - Mike (Host) Thanks for listening to Higgle the B2B Sales Club podcast series with your host, mike Lander. Please subscribe so that you'll catch all the next episodes.